The Hamilton Pistols know that their championship window isn’t as wide open as it used to be. After going to three straight SHL Finals from 2019 to 2021 and winning a pair of Vandys, Hamilton’s core is aging and getting expensive. In 2022, the team struggled with internal dissension and stumbled to a fourth-place finish. Last season, they rebounded to finish second. Both times, their season ended with a playoff loss to the rival Quebec Tigres.
“Teams go in cycles, and obviously, we’re not on the uphill side of our cycle now,” said Pistols coach Keith Shields before the 2024 season began. “But I’m still confident that we’ve got a couple good runs left with this team.”
Shields’ confidence may have taken a hit after the season’s opening week, as the Pistols got off to an 0-4-0 start. Hamilton is the only team that has yet to record a win. Worse yet, the team is struggling at virtually every aspect of the game.
“We suck right now,” said LW Steven Alexander in a typically blunt assessment. “That’s all there is to it. We’ve got to get better quick, or we’re going to get left behind.”
Offensively, Hamilton is tied with the Rhode Island Seekers for last in the league, averaging just 1.5 goals per game. C Calvin Frye, who has scored twice, is the only Pistols players with multiple goals. Alexander has yet to score, with only a pair of assists to his name – and he’s still tied for third on the team in points. Eleven players – more than half Hamilton’s active roster of skaters – have yet to record a point.
The Pistols’ roster lacks depth; due to the high salaries of the team’s stars, the team has had to rely on a revolving cast of youngsters, journeymen, and reclamation projects to fill out the rest of the squad. Their success at doing so has varied over the years, but this year’s motley crew looks especially ragged so far. The team’s bottom six forwards have yet to score; on the second line, only RW Paul Hockenberry has lit the lamp. The Pistols’ three non-Frye centers – Hilliard Macy, Dale Wilcox, and Drustan Zarkovich – are all pointless so far.
“We’ve got a number of new faces here, and it’s taking a while to find some chemistry,” admitted Wilcox. “It’s an adjustment period, for sure.”
Defense has never been Hamilton’s strongest suit, but this year has been even worse than normal. Coverage breakdowns are all too frequent, as the team has been prone to allowing odd-man rushes. The Pistols are allowing 30.3 shots per game; only the Portland Bluebacks and Kansas City Smoke are worse.
“I know we can play better than we have,” said D Clayton “Crusher” Risch. “We’re not playing smart, and we’ve not playing aggressive enough right now. We’re letting other teams get the jump on us.”
Hamilton can typically rely on strong goaltending to cover any defensive lapses. Thus far, though, that’s been another weak point for the club. Their .870 save percentage and 4.25 GAA are dead last in the league. Lasse Koskinen, normally one of the league’s best netminder, is off to an uncharacteristically poor start (0-3-0, 4.33 GAA .877 save percentage). Ageless backup Riley Lattimore was no better, giving up four goals on 25 shots in his first start of the season Saturday.
“My play so far is an embarrassment to me and to the team,” said Koskinen. “I am more responsible than anyone for our losses.”
The perpetually optimistic Shields, however, believes his team will turn things around. “We’re not the first team to have a bad week, and we won’t be the last,” Shields told reporters on Saturday. “We’ve got a lot to work on, obviously, but I’m confident that we’ll get better. I’m not going to panic and claim the sky is falling just because we’ve started off rough.
“Right now, pretty much everyone across the roster isn’t playing up to his ability. That includes the coaching, and myself most of all. But that’s what gives me hope. If we were playing up to our ability and still losing, then I’d be worried.”
Shields pointed to Saturday’s 4-3 loss to the Tigres as a step in the right direction. “Quebec’s been to the Finals the last two years, and we played them tough,” said Shields. “That tells me we’re starting to come around. In a couple of weeks, I’ll bet we’ll be back o the winning track and this [first week] will be forgotten.”
Alexander has a point, however. The East is a highly competitive division, with several strong contenders and other teams like Baltimore on the rise. If the Pistols continue to pile up losses – even competitive ones – they may quickly find themselves in a hole they’ll struggle to climb out of.
“This team’s been too good for too many years to overreact to a slow start,” said Shields. He may well be right. But Hamilton’s window of contention may be closing faster than anyone imagined.