The roster for the 2020 Eastern Division All-Stars, as announced by coach Keith Shields, was as follows:
LW: Steven Alexander, Hamilton. Last year, the voting in the East was dominated by fans of the Pistols and New York Night, the latter of which hosted the game. Without the draw of hosting and with the Night’s lackluster record this year, votes from the New York metro area dipped considerably, while backers of defending champion Hamilton came out in force to support their heroes. Alexander was the league’s top vote-getter, earning his fourth straight trip to the game and his third appearance in the starting lineup. Although the feisty winger’s numbers are not quite up to his career norms, he is tied for the league lead in goals with 21.
D: Clayton “Crusher” Risch, Hamilton. Backed by the voting power of the Greater Toronto Area, Risch was the top vote-getter among Eastern defenseman, making his second All-Star appearance and his first start. The 24-year-old is on track for a career season; he’s already scored more goals in the first half (8) than he ever has in an entire year. He isn’t just an offensive force, either; he continues to deliver strong play in his own end. His 73 blocks is the second-most among Eastern players.
C: Justin Valentine, Hershey. In something of an upset, Valentine managed to hold off Hamilton’s Calvin Frye to make his first All-Star start since 2017. Valentine is the leading man in Hershey’s famous “Love Line,” and he’s producing in line with his top season. He’s currently in third place in goals with 20 and tied for third in points with 42. He’s also among the top ten in plus-minus at +14, a distinction he shares with his fellow Love Liners.
D: Matt Cherner, Boston. In another upset, Cherner surged into second place, ahead of Hershey’s Reese Milton and New York’s Dominic Sanchez, who have been the East’s starting defensemen in each previous All-Star Game. Cherner reportedly benefited from a strong crossover vote, as fans from his previous teams in Dakota and Quebec cast ballots for him in significant numbers. It’s his second All-Star appearance, and his debut representing the East; he showed up on the West’s roster back in 2018. Like his fellow top-pairing blueliner Risch, Cherner has 8 goals and 28 points so far this season.
RW: Claude Lafayette, Hamilton. The Pistols’ rabid voting base lifted Lafayette to his first ever All-Star start (and only his second overall start), appearing alongside his longtime teammate and friend Alexander. Lafayette won his spot by less than 5,000 votes over Hershey’s Christopher Hart and New York’s Rick Nelson. Lafayette is one of the league’s elite passers, and it’s no surprise that he leads the SHL in assists with 35. His 42 points overall ties him with Valentine for the league’s third-highest total.
LW: Lance Sweet, Hershey. Shields mentioned during the lineup announcement that he has a great deal of respect for the Bliss, Hamilton’s fiercest rival. His admiration came through in his picks, as he tapped three Bliss players (in addition to starter Valentine) to the lineup. It’s the second All-Star selection for Sweet, who also appeared in the SHL’s inaugural midseason contest in 2017. Sweet is a highly deserving choice; he leads the league in points with 44, and is in the top 10 in both goals (16) and assists (28).
D: Raymond Smyth, Hamilton. Shields’ respect for Hershey was topped only by his affection for his own squad; the coach selected four players from his Vandy-winning, division-leading Pistols. The veteran Smyth, though, is no homer pick; his 30 points are tied for the highest total among SHL defensemen, and his 26 assists are tied for fifth in the league overall. He also leads the league in plus-minus rating with +17. It’s Smyth’s third trip to the All-Star Game, making a reappearance in the lineup after a one-year absence.
C: Calvin Frye, Hamilton. After Frye was beaten out by Valentine for the starting center spot, there was no doubt that Shields was going to tab his star for a spot. Frye is only of only four Eastern players to have appeared in every All-Star contest to date. Frye is tied with his teammate Alexander for the league lead in goals with 21, and his 43 points is the second highest total in the SHL. “I’ll bet this is the last time for a long time that Calvin isn’t the starter,” said Shields. “If he keeps producing the way he has been, he’s going to make it impossible for the fans to ignore. He’s just a special, special player.”
D: Hercules Mulligan, Hamilton. It’s the third straight All-Star appearance for the 22-year-old Mulligan and the third appearance for a Hamilton defenseman in this lineup. It’s the first time since 2017 that a single team landed a trio of blueliners on the roster; Michigan was the last team to accomplish the feat. The hard-hitting Mulligan brings an extra edge of the Eastern roster; his 68 blocks is sixth in the SHL and second on the Pistols to his linemate Risch.
RW: Christopher Hart, Hershey. Hart joins his linemates Sweet and Valentine on the East roster. Surprisingly, Hart is the only one of the trio who has appeared in every All-Star contest, though he has never started. Like his fellow Love Liners, Hart is in the top ten in the league in points (39), assists (26), and plus-minus (+14). “Last year, I had to carry the Love Line banner all by myself at the game,” said Hart. “This time, I’ll be there with both my brothers, and that’s the way it ought to be.”
LW: Magnus Gunnarson, Hamilton. At a loaded position, Shields tapping his own player again generated some controversy around the league. Many felt that New York’s Chase Winchester or Boston’s Casey Thurman would be a more fitting choice. But Gunnarson is having a strong season in his own right. He has produced 32 points (13 goals, 19 assists) at the halfway point. And when Alexander missed several games with an injury in the first half, Gunnarson stepped in and kept the Pistols from missing a beat. It all adds up to an All-Star debut for the 24-year-old winger.
D: Reese Milton, Hershey. It’s the first time that Milton won’t be starting in an All-Star Game, but the Bliss blueliner keeps his string of appearances alive. Milton’s offensive numbers (8 goals, 17 assists) are a tick below his career norms, but he remains as defensively strong as ever; his 77 blocks are the most in the East, and he maintains a solid +8 rating.
C: Alain Beauchesne, Boston. The 22-year-old Beauchesne receives his second straight All-Star nod; his selection marks the first time that the Badgers have had more than one honoree. This was another somewhat controversial choice: Night fans argued that Brock Manning should have gotten the call, while DC fans clamored for Harvey Bellmore. But Shields went with the youngster, who leads Boston with 32 points (13 goals, 19 assists).
D: Richard McKinley, Quebec. The 21-year-old blueliner is the Tigres’ lone representative this year, and he makes his debut in the All-Star game. Quebec is suffering through considerable offensive struggles this season, but McKinley is a relatively bright spot, having recorded 17 points (5 goals, 12 assists). He also is tied for the team lead in blocks with 65.
RW: Jefferson McNeely, Washington. Like the Tigres, the Galaxy have only one All-Star representative. This season, the honors go to McNeely, who will make his third appearance in the game. He is second on the Washington roster in goals (with 11) and points (with 27). “Honestly, I would have given it to Harvey,” said McNeely. “But it they want me to go again, sure, I’ll go.”
Lasse Koskinen, Hamilton. In a season when many of the East’s traditional top goalies are having down seasons, Koskinen’s solid performance and Hamilton’s strong voting base combined to earn the Pistols netminder his third straight All-Star trip and his second start. Koskinen struggled in the opening weeks of the season, but he has improved as the season has gone along. His 15 wins are second-most in the SHL; that achievement appears to have overshadowed his somewhat-subpar 3.14 GAA and .915 save percentage.
“Jersey Mike” Ross, New York. With Shields in charge of choosing the East’s roster, is it a surprise that Ross is the lone Night player to make the All-Star squad? Perhaps, perhaps not. But the veteran goaltender, who is another first-time All-Star, has had a surprisingly strong season. Believe it or not, Ross has the highest save percentage (.923) among starting goalies in the East. After planned starter Sherman Carter imploded, Ross stepped in as the primary starter and has helped keep the Night afloat in the playoff race.