Through roughly one-quarter of the SHL season, the race in the Eastern Division has defied expectations. As Washington Galaxy RW Jefferson McNeely put it, “If anybody correctly predicted the standings so far, you ought to get to Vegas and start playing the tables, because you must have ESP or something.”
The most shocking storyline by far has been the collapse of the defending champion Hershey Bliss. Widely favored to capture a second straight division title, the Bliss instead fell toward the division basement and have remained there since. Their incredibly slow start hasn’t been the result of injuries (they haven’t suffered any) or key departures from last season (their roster returned largely intact). In fact, the exact cause of their struggles has been a mystery.
After Hershey lost 3-0 in Saskatchewan on Friday to run their losing streak to five, coach “Chocolate Chip” Barber called out his club, saying that the championship had gone to their heads. “When you win a title, that’s a real sugar high,” Barber said. “But after the high comes the crash. We made the mistake of believing our own press. We’ve gone as soft as a bag of Kisses in a hot car on a summer day.” C Justin Valentine, on the other hand, thinks the problem is “mostly bad puck luck, honestly. You look at the underlying numbers, they’re pretty similar to last year. We’re getting the looks and the shots, doing our work on the defensive end, but we’re not getting the breaks.”
One obvious trouble spot for the Bliss is a perennial problem in Chocolate City: goaltending. After Brandon Colt came out of nowhere to win the Finals MVP last season, the hockey world was eager to see if he could repeat the feat. So far, he hasn’t. Colt’s GAA has ballooned nearly a full goal since last season (from 2.77 to 3.68), while his save percentage has plummeted from .909 to .872. Meanwhile Milo Stafford, the ageless backup who defied the skeptics by producing strong numbers year after year, suddenly looks as though he might be washed up at age 36. “It’s a hard time for Milo and me,” said Colt. “We feel like we’re letting the whole team down.”
With Hershey down and out, a couple of surprising teams have jumped up to grab the spotlight. The Hamilton Pistols looked to be a young team on the rise, finishing just below the .500 mark last season. But now it appears they’ve arrived ahead of schedule. After going 3-1-1 on a tough run through the West this week, culminating in a 3-3 tie with mighty Michigan at Cadillac Place, the Pistols ran their record to 11-3-1 and are five points clear in the division.
Last season, Hamilton’s strong top line was dragged down by a lack of depth and experience. GM Marcel LaClaire made some modest but shrewd moves this offseason. He acquired a pair of seasoned veteran leaders in C Henry Constantine and D Craig Werner, and called up a bunch of prospects (wingers Jamie Campbell and Michael Jennings and defensemen Albie Glasco and Buster Kratz) to fix their dismal bottom line. The result has been a high-octane offense that’s scored 62 goals and compiled a +27 rating so far, along with a solid defense in front of Lasse Koskinen, who appears to be the league’s next great netminder.
“Everyone talked about how this wasn’t our year, but we were really going to be something a couple seasons down the road,” said coach Keith Shields. “I told our guys, why the heck shouldn’t it be our year? Don’t let anyone tell you you’re too young or too green to compete. And they sure haven’t! What we’re doing night in and night out is an inspiration.”
Slotted in behind high-flying Hamilton is the Quebec Tigres. Ever since the Tigres joined the league in 2016, they’ve been built on a hard-nosed defense and a great goalie in Riki Tiktuunen. The question was whether they could ever develop a functional offense that would allow them to compete. In their third season, they’ve finally done it. Quebec made a splash in free agency, signing ex-Washington winger Walt Camernitz to a 4-year, $20 million deal. Skeptics wondered whether Camernitz was really worth that much money. The early returns have been extremely encouraging; not only is Camernitz producing at a point-a-game pace so far (7 goals, 9 assists), he’s also sparked his linemates, C Mikhail Ilyushin (6 goals, 13 assists) and RW Stephane Mirac (6 goals, 7 assists). They’ve also added a new top pairing of strong two-way defenders, top draft pick Laurie Workman (4 goals, 6 assists) and minor-league callup Richard McKinley (3 goals, 5 assists). They’ve almost doubled their goal output from the same point last season (from 26 to 44). Their newfound offensive prowess has allowed them to post a 9-6-0 record despite Tiktuunen looking a notch less dominant than usual.
“Before, everyone said the only way we could win was to make the game a bloodbath and win a 1-0 rock fight,” said coach Martin Delorme. “But now we show that you can be a tough, hard-working team and also score the goalies. Perhaps our new uniforms have made us more stylish.”
Lurking close behind Hamilton and Quebec are a pair of familiar foes. The Washington Galaxy were expected to take a step back this season after losing Camernitz and D Patrick Banks. But they’ve shown unexpected resilience, surviving an early injury to C J.C. Marais and posting a solid 8-7-0 record. Their success has been fueled by a resurgence of their top line, led by McNeely. The D.C. star leads the league in points (28) and is tied for the lead in goals (13) with Hamilton’s Steven Alexander. “People rushed to bury us, but we’ve got the experience and the bloodline.”
Meanwhile, the New York Night may be best known for coach Nick Foster‘s attempt to start a feud with Hamilton, but they’ve looked decent so far with a 7-7-1 record. They’ve rediscovered the firepower that went missing last season; after hanging a 10-spot on Seattle Friday, they now lead the league with 63 goals. While their defense remains a mess, much-maligned goalie Jesse Clarkson has quietly provided a steady performance (5-4-0, 3.11 GAA, .913 sv%) that has kept them in games.
“There’s a lot of hockey still to be played,” said Foster. “This division’s still wide open. Stay tuned, ’cause anything can happen.”